Dugongs can be caught and killed in fishing gear, but understanding the scale of this threat is difficult. Conservationists need to know where dugongs occur, where they overlap with fishing activity and how often interactions result in animals being injured or killed. Gathering this information across large coastal areas can require considerable time, money and fieldwork.
Fishers can help fill some of these gaps. Spending extensive time on the water, they may have firsthand knowledge of dugong sightings, accidental catches and animals found dead. Interviews can draw on this knowledge to build a picture of dugong distribution and reported fishing-related mortality, helping conservationists identify areas where further investigation may be needed.
The CMS Dugong Catch and Bycatch Questionnaire provides a standardised way to collect this information. It was used across five countries during the IKI Seagrass Ecosystem Services Project: Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand and Timor-Leste. Experiences from the project illustrate both the value of collecting information from fishers and the challenges of turning their reports into evidence that can inform conservation.
Drawing on an interview with Dr Nicolas Pilcher of the Marine Research Foundation, who has been involved in developing and implementing the questionnaire, this article examines how the approach was used during the project and what its experience reveals about the opportunities and limitations of collecting information from fishers.

What was the questionnaire designed to do?
The CMS Dugong Catch and Bycatch Questionnaire builds on the Rapid Bycatch Assessment approach developed by Jeff Moore and colleagues in 2010. It was adapted for dugongs to provide a relatively low-cost way of collecting information about their distribution and interactions with fisheries. It also gathers information about marine turtles and cetaceans. Since its introduction, the questionnaire has been used in 18 dugong range States, with over 7,800 respondents recorded across its deployments.1,2
The questionnaire asks fishers and other coastal water users about dugong sightings, catches, fishing practices and changes they have observed over time. These responses can be considered alongside information on fishing activity and mapped to examine where reported dugong observations and fishing grounds overlap.
The results are not intended to provide a population estimate or a definitive measure of how many dugongs are killed in fishing gear. Instead, they can help identify potential areas of concern and indicate where more detailed surveys or investigations may be worthwhile.
As Pilcher explained:
“We weren’t sort of fooling ourselves to think that we were going to have scientifically replicable data. That wasn’t the objective.”
The aim is to gather enough information to help direct attention, rather than to answer every question about dugong populations or bycatch. As Pilcher put it:
“When you’ve got fishing here and dugongs here, then you might want to start paying attention.”
The original approach was designed to be relatively inexpensive, with a reported average cost of around US$5,000 per country. Actual costs will depend on how the questionnaire is implemented and the resources available. 1
What did this look like during IKI?

© Yapeka, Indonesia. 2020
The IKI Seagrass Ecosystem Services Project ran from 2020 to 2024 across Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand and Timor-Leste. Its work combined seagrass assessment, ecosystem-service research, community engagement and work on sustainable financing and local conservation. The catch and bycatch questionnaire provided one source of information within this broader programme. 3,4
Implementation was not identical across the participating countries. In Indonesia, around 500 questionnaires were planned across two locations. In Sangihe, 181 interviews had been completed by late 2020, with a further 80 in North Sulawesi. Training that would normally have taken place in person was moved online because of COVID-19 restrictions. It covered the questionnaire itself, trial interviews, spatial data and data entry, before teams began fieldwork. 3,4
The fieldwork also illustrated some of the practical limitations of collecting this type of information. Internet connectivity in Sangihe was unreliable, while restrictions on access to communities affected how teams could work during the pandemic. Despite these constraints, local teams were able to collect information from fishers and other coastal users.
The resulting information could reveal patterns that were not immediately obvious from looking at individual observations. In Sangihe, for example, observations initially appeared relatively scattered. Looking more closely at the spatial data showed a concentration around a particular seamount, an area where local fishers already knew where to find dugongs. The questionnaire did not necessarily generate entirely new knowledge. Rather, it provided a structured way of recording local observations and examining their relationship with fishing activity.
The interviews could also provide information that was difficult to obtain from ecological surveys alone. In North Sulawesi, for example, interviews recorded continued hunting of dugongs and turtles, including reports of dugong meat being used at wedding celebrations, even though many people interviewed were aware that dugongs were legally protected. 7 This provided information about how legal protection, local practices and perceptions existed alongside one another.
These examples point to one of the practical advantages of the method: its usefulness did not depend on every interview producing a new scientific observation. Information from fishers could be combined with spatial data, existing ecological knowledge and other project activities to indicate where particular issues might warrant closer attention.
What happened when the circumstances were different?
The experience in Timor-Leste showed the other side of this. Only 45 questionnaires were completed, and implementation was very limited. COVID-19, changes in project leadership and changing priorities affected how the work progressed.
There was also a methodological consequence to the way the work had been planned. Survey locations had already been selected before the questionnaire was introduced. This reduced the extent to which the results could be used to identify where attention should be focused in the first place.

© Blue Ventures
This was less a problem with the questionnaire itself than a consequence of how it fitted into the wider project. The method was designed to help identify patterns and possible areas of concern, but that function is reduced when locations and priorities have already been determined through another process.
Malaysia provided another example of why implementation cannot be separated from what has already been done. The questionnaire was not repeated during IKI in an area where an earlier GEF project had already collected comparable information. There was therefore little reason to repeat the exercise simply to generate another dataset.
The contrast between these examples is useful. A standardised questionnaire creates a common structure for collecting information, but it does not mean that every application will produce the same type or quantity of information. Previous surveys, project priorities, access to communities, training and local capacity all affect what can ultimately be collected and how it can be interpreted.
What happens to the information?
The people collecting the questionnaires were generally national or local organisations working within their own programmes. The resulting information therefore remained connected to the organisations and communities from which it came, rather than becoming a central dataset held by the technical advisers supporting the work.
The distinction was expressed simply:
“It’s their data. It’s not mine.”
This affects how the information can be used. Local organisations can combine questionnaire results with their own field observations, local knowledge, previous surveys and conservation priorities. The same information can therefore have a different practical use depending on who is working with it and what decisions they are trying to make.
The IKI experience also shows that standardising a questionnaire does not make the resulting data independent of how, where and by whom it is implemented. Differences in training, access to communities, project priorities and previous surveys affected what could be collected in each location. In some cases, the questionnaire helped reveal patterns that could be investigated further; in others, its use was more limited by the circumstances of the project than by the method itself.
The resulting information is therefore closely tied to the organisations and people who collect and use it. The questionnaire provides a structured record of observations and fishing activity, but what can be done with that information depends on how it is combined with local knowledge, other evidence and the conservation decisions being made on the ground.
Further Reading:
https://dugong.cms.int/project/cms-dugong-mou-standardised-catch-and-bycatch-questionnaire
References
[1] Pilcher, N.J. et al. (2017). A low-cost solution for documenting distribution and abundance of endangered marine fauna and impacts from fisheries. PLOS ONE, 12(12), e0190021.
[2] Convention on Migratory Species (CMS). CMS Dugong MOU Standardised Catch and Bycatch Questionnaire.
[3] Marine Research Foundation. IKI Seagrass Ecosystem Services Project.
[4] Seagrass-Watch. IKI Seagrass Ecosystem Services Project.
[5] Convention on Migratory Species (CMS) (2020). Adapting to the COVID-19 pandemic: Remote training for the Dugong Catch and Bycatch Questionnaire.
[6] Dugong & Seagrass Hub. Adapting to the COVID-19 pandemic: Remote training for Dugong Catch and Bycatch Questionnaire.
[7] Dugong & Seagrass Hub. Adapting to the COVID-19 pandemic: Remote training for Dugong Catch and Bycatch Questionnaire.